Quantcast
Managing Risk In An Unstable World
Celebrity Fires Consume the Media
Daschle-Obama Health Care Possibilities
Failure To Blow Election Stuns Democratic Party Faithful Mourn End To Losing Tradition
Hungry For Change And Simply Hungry
Thanksgiving - Thanking God
Good Time For A Brainy President
Obama Priority is to Remake America
Socialist Republic
Christmas as a Contact Sport
About That New New Deal
Welcome To America
And They're Off
The Teflon President-Elect
Erbe: If Citicorp, Why Not GM?
Giving Thanks
Thanksgiving In Transition
So Much For Letting The Free Market Rule
Financial Rescue: Bolder Beats Bigger
The Hysterical Style
Findings
Health Care Reform Must Start Now
Giving Thanks To America's Good Food Movement
Hillary Plus Obama Equals High Drama
The Least Of These
Drafting Ken Blackwell
Cutting Costs In A Tough Economy
The Ghosts Of Desert Storm
Will Obama Opt For Pragmatism In Energy Policy?
A Lemon Of A Bailout
For America To Survive, Obama Must Be Economically Flexible
Mormons In The Crosshairs
From One Stereotype To Another
Time To Refocus On Less Materialism, Simpler Life
Giving Thanks For Self-Reliant Americans
Sarah Palin Is Not The Future Of The GOP
Washington Experience Is 'In' Again
What Is Happening With The Economy?
Uncle Sam's Bipolar Bailout Disorder
Country First?
Privatizing Piracy Protection
Barack Obama's Blackberry Blues
Stressed Parents Cry Out For Help
Why Reporters -- And Judges And Professors -- Are Biased
Just Call Her Madam Secretary
The Gift of the Magi Revisited
Change is Changing
Blessed Are The Caregivers
America's In Trouble, And Immigrants Are Part Of The Solution
When The Warmest In History Isn't
Obama Picks Foxes To Guard Henhouse
Domestic Partner Registry -- Well, It's A Start
Whatever Happened To Accountability?
GOP Senator: We Haven't Learned
Memories of a neocon -- Interview with Ben Wattenberg
The Return Of British Socialism
Blind Defense of Koran Abrogates Reality
Some Of My Best Friends Are…
Free Ride For The Campus Left
Trade Versus Protectionism
Picking New York's Next Senator



The Future of Editorial Cartoons
September 22, 2008
Digg This Story!
Del.icio.usRedditStumbleUponYahoo! MyWebTechnoratiGoogle BookmarksFurlMa.gnoliaNewsvineBloglinesRojoFacebook

One of our good foreign customers wrote to me, and to a batch of top international cartoonists asking them what they thought the future of editorial cartooning would be. Here is my response:

I disagree with most of my cartoonist colleagues on this - most cartoonists view the future creatively, arguing that there will be more animation in cartoons and more cartoons created to take advantage of the interactivity of the internet. I disagree, because I also run a syndicate and I see no trend for web customers to be willing to pay for interactive or animated cartoons. This is just cartoonists describing what they hope will happen.

The big change I see happening is the decline of big newspapers, and an increase in small clients, free weekly newspapers and non-traditional clients who would not buy cartoons before, because the process was too difficult or expensive. As the big publishers die off and cut back, we pick up new small web sites, newsletters, weeklies and foreign publications, which wouldn't have found us before, if not for the internet.

The future is not a change in the nature of cartoons, which remain popular in their current, static form, it is a change in distribution of cartoons to more clients, smaller clients, and more obscure clients in more faraway places, as publications become smaller and more numerous, as more people become easier to reach and as more people around the world have interests in the same issues.


Posted By: Dorian Benkoil  on Monday, September 22, 2008

Could the future of editorial cartooning be that you publish them and aggregate your own audience, which you then "monetize" -- without the need for clients, big or small?


Posted By: Vanessa  on Monday, September 22, 2008

So do you expect that what cartoonists really need is to develop more creative forms of getting paid, such as (I'm brainstorming here) paying for various levels of RSS feeds?  Since in my experience people often prefer to have things automatically delivered to their electronic doorstep.


Posted By: Good Life  on Monday, September 22, 2008

In Ames IA they have a paper everyone reads.  It's called "Toons" and is a free shopper type that's half advertising and half cartoons.  Seems like a great idea to steal if I knew how.


Posted By: Daryl Cagle  on Monday, September 22, 2008

Most cartoonists describe dealing with the changes in media by describing how they will draw their cartoons differently (animation, interactivity) rather than how they will sell their cartoons differently.



We all have to figure out how to deal with lots of little clients who don’t pay much, rather than wishing for the old days when cartoonists could depend on one newspaper for a job.  That said, there are lots and lots more little clients now – increasing every day in both print and web.  I’m coming at it from the direction of syndication, but I expect to see more business models for cartoonists and writers and I’m eager to embrace any new ideas that work.  



Getting past the resistance of web readers to pay for anything is a big hurdle.  I don’t see animation and interactivity in cartoons breaking through that barrier.  I haven’t been able to make a business out of putting cartoons on the web; I still make most of the business out of syndication to print, with the web sites and books supporting that.  It works for me, but I’d like to see it work much better and I’m searching around for new answers too.




Posted By: Tom Wood  on Tuesday, September 23, 2008

I'm hoping Dorian is right, that there's a way to attract your own audience and bypass the gatekeepers. Such a site would be more like a blog, I'm calling mine (wendelbrume.com) a clog - a cartoon log. It's animated, so I'm working at streamlining the production so I can comment via cartoon frequently. In addition to RSS, there's now MRSS - Media RSS and the whole issue of SEO - Search Engine Optimization. Getting on the web is just the starting point, getting found is the challenge.



Once found, the next hurdle is to get enough traffic so you can join an ad network. (And I'm not talking Adsense.) The larger ones want something on the order of 15,000 hits a day. Daunting but not impossible. With ads served to the site it's free to the viewer.



But with editorial cartoons, there's the added resistance of advertisers not wanting to have their ads run against anything "controversial". Tell me again why this is fun?

Make A Comment
We appreciate your feedback. Post a comment using the form below.
Your Name (required)
Your Comments
Type the characters you see in the image: